alternatehistory.com
Forums
New posts
Search forums
What's new
New posts
New profile posts
New threadmarks
Latest activity
Members
Registered members
Current visitors
New profile posts
Search profile posts
Log in
Register
What's new
Search
Search
Search titles only
By:
Word Count:
Registered members
Current visitors
New profile posts
Search profile posts
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Members
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Catspoke's latest activity
Catspoke
reacted to
raharris1973's post
in the thread
AHWI: No schlieffen plan
with
Like
.
You're correct - that's how it works best as a militarily supported alliance-diplomatic strategy, in support of their Austrian ally's...
Yesterday at 7:33 PM
Catspoke
replied to the thread
AHWI: No schlieffen plan
.
The "demonstrations of military superiority" assumptions are more likely to be right if the Germans don't actually DOW anybody, Austria...
Yesterday at 4:18 PM
Catspoke
replied to the thread
Russia and Germany as allies in an alternate WW1
.
Germany and Russia have a not in dispute 1815 Congress of Vienna boundary, no reason they couldn't just be Allies. Both don't want more...
Yesterday at 11:12 AM
Catspoke
reacted to
raharris1973's post
in the thread
AHWI: No schlieffen plan
with
Like
.
This can work for Germany to *win* a *diplomatic* victory, security by a live, lethal, expensive demonstration of military superiority...
Thursday at 8:38 PM
Catspoke
replied to the thread
Is a successful 1918 Spring Offensive possible?
.
Focus on attacking the French, attack at the Chemin Des Damme's first (instead of in May, rollup the French line east, encircling...
Tuesday at 3:24 PM
Catspoke
replied to the thread
AHWI: No schlieffen plan
.
The OP didn't mention the usual east first. So Germany could still do west first but without invading Belgium, if so it might make some...
Tuesday at 2:58 PM
Catspoke
reacted to
1962strat's post
in the thread
AHWI: No schlieffen plan
with
Like
.
It's also worth noting that both the geography and layout of the railways mean that Belgium provides way more value to the Germans than...
Tuesday at 2:43 PM
Catspoke
replied to the thread
What if Britain lost World War I.
.
If Germany wins in 1916 1917, Britain does ok, no colonial losses, her dominions pick up gains, Britain probably keeps southern Iraq to...
Monday at 8:19 PM
Catspoke
reacted to
Nivek's post
in the thread
WI: Kühlmann's "Peace Kite" Flies, a Negotiated End to WWI in 1917?
with
Like
.
Because people here ignore reality
Monday at 4:29 PM
Catspoke
reacted to
Germaniac's post
in the thread
What if Churchill didn't under-estimate the Turks at gallipoli?
with
Like
.
As others have noted, the plan was to run the fleet up the Bosporus, regardless of losses, and force the Ottomans to surrender by...
Monday at 12:02 PM
Catspoke
reacted to
Garrison's post
in the thread
WI: Kühlmann's "Peace Kite" Flies, a Negotiated End to WWI in 1917?
with
Like
.
Problem is that might actually be worse than OTL owing to the blockade still being in place and in 1917 they still think there's a...
May 10, 2024
Catspoke
replied to the thread
WI: Kühlmann's "Peace Kite" Flies, a Negotiated End to WWI in 1917?
.
I think Britain/France would insist upon evacuation of France/Belgium and Alsace-Lorraine first, then do a cease fire/negotiations. At...
May 10, 2024
Catspoke
reacted to
Garrison's post
in the thread
WI: Kühlmann's "Peace Kite" Flies, a Negotiated End to WWI in 1917?
with
Like
.
Which is just typical 'lions led by donkeys' mythology. Even at the height of the French mutiny in 1917 the French army was able and...
May 10, 2024
Catspoke
replied to the thread
WI: Hitler dies in Autumn 1941
.
Which is why peace won't happen, peace can happen only if both sides think they are weak. Really about 10 days in October when the...
May 9, 2024
Catspoke
replied to the thread
WI: Hitler dies in Autumn 1941
.
The Generals wanted to do Typhoon, both first and second phases, and wanted to do a lot of the OTL divergence to the secondary...
May 9, 2024
Members
Top