To think again about the conquests Italy has done until 1939, i became a bit baffled towards the fact that Anton Mussert decided to model his political thinking after someone whose empire is only 11 times larger than the fatherland, compared to the Dutch's 45 times larger.

But i guess greed has no bounds, eh? And to be fair the Italian colonial possession is still almost 2 times larger than the Dutch's. And also combined Benelux would make their colonial empires bigger than Italy's.
Italy's colonies were resource drains.
 
Again, my main point of the post is that fascism is inherently irrational. Revolving about land-grabbing for national pride, reliving past glories, supremacism (cultural or racial), and whatnot.
I think we're going to see the the Algerians be killed in Algeria more than anything else. Algeria was administered by the French as part of France proper, and I'd imagine a lot of the natives there would revolt like otl, and France probably would kill a lot of them to make space for French speakers.

But I'd agree that French Jews probably would have a terrible time in Action Francaise, it's just that it wouldn't be 'millions of people'. Only war in Germany would wrack up that number otherwise.

I do wonder if we'd still get something like Israel popping up despite no Nazis bc of Stalin. A more severe doctor's plot ittl would be a good catalyst for it, and if France goes to slaughter their own Jews I could see a mass exodus of Jews to Israel as they're scared. But I have to admit I'm not too well versed in the history around this, so yeah. I think an Arabian Palestine would be just as interesting.
I am also a bit surprised that no one has brought up the fact that Maurras and the Integralists getting the aid of the Fascists is going to lead to a really unhappy marriage. After all, Integralism opposed a lot of the things that Fascism (at least of the Italian kind) advocated for, like French cultural superiority and assimilation, plus colonial hegemony. What you get from combinding those two is a very unhappy marriage that can only work as long as they have a common enemy.
 
I am also a bit surprised that no one has brought up the fact that Maurras and the Integralists getting the aid of the Fascists is going to lead to a really unhappy marriage. After all, Integralism opposed a lot of the things that Fascism (at least of the Italian kind) advocated for, like French cultural superiority and assimilation, plus colonial hegemony. What you get from combinding those two is a very unhappy marriage that can only work as long as they have a common enemy.
And it doesn't help that Integralism and Fascism had different worldviews as well, with how Integralism was an arch-reactionary ideology that looked to a romanticized view of the ancien regime while Fascism was a "revolutionary nationalist" ideology with a worldview based around "modernity without democracy", especially with how Mussolini started out a socialist before moving to the right ideologically and Fascism's roots started out in "national syndicalism" as well.
 
And it doesn't help that Integralism and Fascism had different worldviews as well, with how Integralism was an arch-reactionary ideology that looked to a romanticized view of the ancien regime while Fascism was a "revolutionary nationalist" ideology with a worldview based around "modernity without democracy", especially with how Mussolini started out a socialist before moving to the right ideologically and Fascism's roots started out in "national syndicalism" as well.
Exactly. Plus the supremacy of your culture was a big part of Fascism, whereas Maurras's whole thing was a "unifying France" which transcended ideology.
 

Garrison

Donor
Ah yes that rosy past, where men were men, women were women, and casual racism was everywhere...
A nice update and I can see how Anglo-French relations are going to get fraught. If Mussolini starts publicly musing about the Suez Canal things could get very unpleasant very fast.
Of course IOTL it was signing the treaty with the Germans that triggered the pro-allied coup, which backfired spectacularly as it gave the Germans the excuse they needed to invade. Be interesting here if at some point German troops are arriving to defend Yugoslavia.
 

Garrison

Donor
hotpoit.ai was the one I used (shoutout to @eliamartin65 for getting me into that). You will see AI help come in a few times throughout the story for certain buildings or people of which we don't have real pictures, but which I wanted to depict
Alt history may be the most valid use for AI imagery, things that you just can't find and would otherwise require who knows how long with Photoshop for something that's just meant to add a bit of colour to the TL.
 
Alt history may be the most valid use for AI imagery, things that you just can't find and would otherwise require who knows how long with Photoshop for something that's just meant to add a bit of colour to the TL.
One of the fun things to play with has been looking at alternate architecture. It definitely screws up sometimes, but looking for things like alternate palaces or cityscapes is very cool
 
The fact that he made no move to do so, as well as his willingness to cede greater and greater powers to his Prime Minister, played a crucial role in the loss of popular support during the last years of the fascist regime and, eventually, culminated in the end of the Italian monarchy itself.
"Much of the suffering my and many other peoples endured could have been avoided if different choices had been made when Italian troops crossed the Abyssinian border in 1935. If the Great Powers had been willing to set aside their egos and work together in the interest of collective security, instead of playing tug-of-war over scraps, perhaps my father and my kingdom could have avoided their eventual horrible fates.” - Prince Nicholas of Yugoslavia, 1968
A shame that the Italian and Yugoslavian monarchies are destined to fall ttl as well. The Italian monarchy really wasn’t destined to fall otl afaik
All they had to do was wait and trust Mussolini. He and he alone could lead them to victory.
Sure, Jan
 
A shame that the Italian and Yugoslavian monarchies are destined to fall ttl as well. The Italian monarchy really wasn’t destined to fall otl afaik

Sure, Jan
I was on the fence for a long time about that, as well as whether I should risk writing myself into a corner by outright referencing it this early, but to be honest, I think the Italian monarchy won't have a chance. Victor Emmanuel was too poor of a ruler and had too much power to survive such close ties to Mussolini. Plus, without the benefit of falling into the shadow of literal Nazis, I see their enemies being much less willing to go as easy on them as IRL after the fact
 
A shame that the Italian and Yugoslavian monarchies are destined to fall ttl as well. The Italian monarchy really wasn’t destined to fall otl afaik

Sure, Jan
On that note, I am betting that the horrible fate of Yugoslavia, for starters, includes the Ustase doing their thing (for context, these people operated the only extermination camp outside of German jurisdiction IOTL).
 
I was on the fence for a long time about that, as well as whether I should risk writing myself into a corner by outright referencing it this early, but to be honest, I think the Italian monarchy won't have a chance. Victor Emmanuel was too poor of a ruler and had too much power to survive such close ties to Mussolini. Plus, without the benefit of falling into the shadow of literal Nazis, I see their enemies being much less willing to go as easy on them as IRL after the fact
I suppose that’s fair. If Italy is punished hard after a ttl ww2, would it be possible for a re-seperation of the Two Sicilies? Then that kingdom could at least be restored. They were more pro-monarchy in that part of the country. It would probably be the Sicilian Bourbons and not the Savoyards though
On that note, I am betting that the horrible fate of Yugoslavia, for starters, includes the Ustase doing their thing (for context, these people operated the only extermination camp outside of German jurisdiction IOTL).
Well that certainly is a horrifying thought…
 
I suppose that’s fair. If Italy is punished hard after a ttl ww2, would it be possible for a re-seperation of the Two Sicilies? Then that kingdom could at least be restored. They were more pro-monarchy in that part of the country. It would probably be the Sicilian Bourbons and not the Savoyards though
It would depend on a lot of factors which would constitute spoilers, but I think it is possible. The main issue with doing so, however, is the question of Rome since very few would want to see a reborn Papal State. And completely shattering Italy would be as bad as shattering Germany in terms of creating another enemy
 
It would depend on a lot of factors which would constitute spoilers, but I think it is possible. The main issue with doing so, however, is the question of Rome since very few would want to see a reborn Papal State. And completely shattering Italy would be as bad as shattering Germany in terms of creating another enemy
And I assume my psychic powers predicted once more that the Ustase are going to unleash hell on earth as part of what has been implied to happen to Yugoslavia? :p
 
And I assume my psychic powers predicted once more that the Ustase are going to unleash hell on earth as part of what has been implied to happen to Yugoslavia? :p
I can neither confirm nor deny the possibility of your psychic powers once again proving frustratingly accurate in finding one of the big factors which will badly destabilise and lead to a great deal of suffering in Yugoslavia
 
It would depend on a lot of factors which would constitute spoilers, but I think it is possible. The main issue with doing so, however, is the question of Rome since very few would want to see a reborn Papal State. And completely shattering Italy would be as bad as shattering Germany in terms of creating another enemy
Very true. Could it be as simple as just Splitting Italy in two? The Two Sicilies as one state and the rest as another?
 
Top