An alternative view of Beatle history

This show is on BBC Radio 2 tonight, and sound very interesting, so I thought I'd start a thread so we can discuss it. It will be on iPlayer if anyone misses it at 10pm.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b08rfqk3

An alternative view of Beatle history
Paul Merton's BeatlesEpisode 1 of 4

The year is 1974. Labour's Harold Wilson is Britain's Prime Minister, and Richard Nixon is in the White House. Abba win Eurovision, Germany win the World Cup and a new writer called Stephen King publishes his first novel.

After 5 years of tension, ill feeling and fraught negotiation the four Beatles have buried their individual hatchets and are moving tentatively towards a full scale reunion, hopefully culminating in their first new album since 1969.

As a warm up for the recording sessions, the Beatles - and some of their famous friends - have come together once more for a surprise concert, their first time live on stage since 1966 when they gave up live appearances after a show at Candlestick Park in San Francisco.
Join Paul Merton on the commentator's microphone as the Fab Four take to the boards once more....

Well, kind of. Well, all right, not at all. Not really.

Like all of us, Paul Merton is a huge Beatles fan and like all Beatle fans his mind often turns to the "What if's..." of their career.

What if they'd never broken up? What if they were still playing live? What if they made another album?

This four part series is Paul's attempt to answer those questions, and to put forward a fantastical version of Beatle history.

Based on the known facts, and using the recordings available, he imagines the concert that the Beatles could have given, and follows it up with the album that they could have made.

The result is a fascinating look into an alternative reality, but also a clear eyed examination of the strengths and of the forces that drove - and drove apart - the greatest band of all time.

It never happened, but it could have. Couldn't it?
 
It turns out this was just a mix of solo live tracks, with a presenter connecting them as though they were a "Beatles" concert. No real discussion of how it happens in this alt world, from what I could hear.
 
It turns out this was just a mix of solo live tracks, with a presenter connecting them as though they were a "Beatles" concert. No real discussion of how it happens in this alt world, from what I could hear.

Yeah I was slightly disappointed by the lack of the 'how' and 'why' the Beatles got back together.

The music was great, different bits of post Beatle band members covering their old tracks as far as I could tell, but mixed and sound matched quite well.

Hopefully the other 3 parts will dive into the Alt history side more.
 
If it turns into "George Harrison dies, the albums are disliked, and everything is terrible. Vietnam somehow becomes worse. Mister Rogers spontaneously combusts. F your hope, because actual history is the best world because F your hope." as so much alternate history does, I'll be disappointed.
 
Top