The Day of the Lion: An Italian WW2 TL

Un popolo alla macchia
Un popolo alla macchia


1710007526994.png




Ambrosio was desperate to establish a direct link with the Allied commands but felt unable to leave Rome for direct talks. The reputation of the military regime had been badly damaged by the events of Mussolini’s death and its de facto leader did not want to leave the capital, having forbidden any evacuation. He sent General Castellano to Naples to plead with the American commander, General Mark Clark on his behalf.

The requests were met with continued assurances of help at a future date and questions in return about the stability of the new Italian regime particularly in light of their inability to protect the captive Mussolini.

Throughout Autumn the Allied armies would successfully establish themselves throughout Central and Southern Italy. They brought a sense of militaristic stability to those regions they occupied; however the new regime in Rome appeared to wield little influence outside of the capital. With the disruption to Italian infrastructure limiting print news and with only 4% of Italian homes owning a radio, the capital became more distant to most Italians than at any time since unification.

In many areas the old Fascist administration was largely intact, with only the most overt PNF officials having been removed or otherwise dispatched and the remainder simply swapping allegiance from Mussolini to the King. Indeed in the case of some prefectures this involved ‘practical’ officials who had previously embraced Fascism only after Mussolini’s rise to power.

The aftershocks of over a month of disruption to Italian infrastructure, whether from bombing, revolution or invasion, was beginning to take its toll on the already tenuous food supply. The exodus of refugees fleeing the German advance in northern Italy would dwarf the flight from Catania and numbered in the millions. It was a journey filled with danger; rough terrain, little access to food and shelter and for many no end destination.

Italy remained largely regional despite two decades of Fascist attempts to mould the nation into a single corporate organism and the differences between northerners and southerners sharpened with the influx of northern refugees in southern regions already facing severe shortages. The famine of 1944 would exacerbate these divisions to breaking point but in the Summer of 1943 it was already taking its toll on the social fabric..

Nonetheless with what remained of its effective military force concentrated around Rome, and the prestige control of the capital offered, the legitimacy of the Caviglia regime remained the closest thing to a functional Italian government in 1943 even whilst the German advance continued largely unchecked.

The modern heavy tanks of the SS swept south through the ancient cities of Modena, Parma and Reggio Emilia with minimal resistance; a protracted defence of Bologna was attempted by veterans of the Eastern Front and the local workers committee only for shortages in ammunition and equipment causing the besieged city to fall after a few days of heavy fighting. It was another bitter reminder of how Mussolini’s African and Russian campaigns had left the Italian Army unable to defend its own country.

The Germans would halt their march at Rimini infamously on orders from Fuhrer Military Headquarters rather than from any Allied or Italian pressure. It was a defeat worse than Carporetto had been for the Italian army both in scale and significance. In 1917 the panic caused by the rout of Italian forces had crucially turned to determined resistance and eventual victory against an exhausted foe. This time there had only been collapse and confusion hung in the air as to whether the Germans would consolidate their gains or march further south.

An air of helplessness surrounded the Italian Army which inevitably impacted the new regime they had established and exacerbated the sense of no-one being really in charge throughout much of Italy. The lack of information available to the centre and south sometimes mitigated knowledge of the extent of the disaster. Elsewhere rumours made it appear even worse with stories of the Germans seizing Rome and being nearby whichever location the gossip spread. Occasionally arriving Allied troops were presumed to be the Germans, causing panic rather than relief and occasional violence.

Despite the initial fears of Ambrosio there was no organised attempt at restoring Fascism to take advantage of the chaos. Fascist demonstrations would occur throughout August, particularly in areas overrun by the German advance; however the coup and the subsequent defection of its national leadership had left the movement decapitated. Local leaders had often sought to shield themselves from reprisal rather than plan to retake power.

Such demonstrations were typically accompanied by violence as anti-fascists, angry and emboldened, met the Blackshirts. The results of these altercations often depended on whether they were being broken up by Allied or German troops.

The German advance matched a similar route the Blackshirts had taken in crushing socialist and trade union activity in successive northern cities prior to the March on Rome; however it quickly began clear that the fortunes of Italian Fascism had faded with the abortive ‘Fascist Freedom Army’.

The Blackshirt attempts at reasserting their authority on the streets of northern towns and cities fared only slightly better in German-occupied territory. The SS had been chosen for their ideological commitment to Fascism however their brutality against occupied peoples did not make theoretical distinctions. It was soon to be concluded that the Fascists had failed to take advantage of German assistance in reviving their nation and as such had proven themselves unworthy of further cooperation. Mussolini was dead and, in Hitler’s eyes, Italy should die with him.

Roberto Farinacci would eventually gain German approval to reestablish the PNF in order to assist the German occupation and exploitation of Northern Italy. The former Party Secretary pledged to rebuild the party based only on loyal cadres and avoid the “hangers-on” he had first warned about in 1924. In doing so he pledged to revive the Fascist state and thus Italy itself. It was a delusion which would go on to ensure Italian Fascist complicity in the nightmare of the Operational Zones.

The SS were already giving Italians a taste of the new order in forcing the population of Rimini and the surrounding into the construction of fortifications. It was a round-up some local Blackshirts were happy to assist in and their collaboration was welcome. The Germans dug-in and prepared to renew their advance not further south but towards Milan.


---
 
Great update! Interesting to see the unravelling of Italy in TTL...

Small quibble: while researching my own TL, i was shocked by the unpopularity of Farinacci even among the Germans after 1940/41. I highly doubt Hitler would have him step up and lead the RSI in TTL, though he likely will play a larger role than OTL without BM there. Rodolfo Granziani would be a better choice in your TL than Farinacci IMHO. After Mussolini, he was one of the highest profile fascists to participate in the RSI.
 
Just a note, it's difficult to see that many italians going towards south, while there were millions of 'sfollati' in OTL there was also a more slow and steady advance that kept a lot of railway link usefull and also many inhabitantants of the city (my family included) gone in the countryside (were the possibility to found food is better) even because the road will be difficult to use, the railway a target and what little is functional will be used by the military, plus there is the big obstacle of the Appenin.
Basically except people that left for the South before or in the immediate of the invasion, the greater bulk of the italians will be forced to remain in North Italy.

And now my usual remark towards the Allies...i know i look like a broken record but at this stage and with the foreshadowing of the famine of 1944 well the allied command need to take one a decision as if they left things on the own it's soo clear to be embarassing (really at the moment even a blind, mute, deaf and with some cerebral lesion individual will understand how grimm the situation is for the Caviglia government) that the current italian government will collapse and they will have on their hand an enourmous basketcase that will greatly hinder their operation so they need to activate some braincells and decide if they want to take direct control of the place or start give some seriouis help or even just some help. Even because Winston in London want to at least puppetize Italy and there is need an Italy left to puppetize and for now the only one that are making some serious inroad are the communist and this will not make him happy
 
As I understand it, the territory of RSI is much smaller than OTL. This could have the advantage that the defense forces can be much better concentrated and thus much more difficult to break through. The entire coastline to be defended is also smaller, which makes it more difficult for the Allies to carry out cargo operations here.

Have Germany and Croatia already annexed Italian territories such as Tyrol or Dalmatia?
 
Yep but even start giving older allied equipment to the italian armed forces to start the reequipment wil help morale and at least give the government something to show so to say: please hold the line till things are better.
Not considering any help on the food situation, expecially in the zone where the Germans had operated and plundered everything.

Whether the equipment's new or old it comes down to shipping although with the Allies firmly cemented on the peninsula there will be support given to rebuilding the Italian army the shortages of food and what the Allies are willing to spare whilst preparing for Overlord will become a source for frayed relations as well.

As a side note, the general situation of the Germans is a lot worse than OTL, they have not only lost the troops in Italy but they have been engaged in the conquest of north Italy that had not be really cheap in term of men and material...and it's not completed, plus the italian contingents in the balkans have put a much harder fight than OTL with many joining the various resistance forces or being evacauted.
Not considering that unlike OTL they don't have captured that many equipment to utilize and prisoners to use as slave labor

Yeah the whole thing really is a disaster for the Germans; the relative strength of their industry has allowed them to be slightly more resilient than the Italians but not by much. The Heer has been in transistion from a primarily offensive to primarily defensive force and their ability to carry that out has been badly stretched.

Great update! Interesting to see the unravelling of Italy in TTL...

Thanks!

Small quibble: while researching my own TL, i was shocked by the unpopularity of Farinacci even among the Germans after 1940/41. I highly doubt Hitler would have him step up and lead the RSI in TTL, though he likely will play a larger role than OTL without BM there. Rodolfo Granziani would be a better choice in your TL than Farinacci IMHO. After Mussolini, he was one of the highest profile fascists to participate in the RSI.

That's really not surprising given that Mussolini himself had a dossier of dirt on Farinacci and was ready to ruin him even whilst elevating him to powerful positions. I suppose it comes down to what degree they can tolerate him, my source came from the meetings at the Berghof in reaction to Mussolini's removal from power where Hitler suggests potentially propping up Farinacci. It's worth remembering that there is no RSI-equivalent Italian puppet state here, a reconstitued PNF under Farinacci is tolerated in order for it to assist the military occupation.

Just a note, it's difficult to see that many italians going towards south, while there were millions of 'sfollati' in OTL there was also a more slow and steady advance that kept a lot of railway link usefull and also many inhabitantants of the city (my family included) gone in the countryside (were the possibility to found food is better) even because the road will be difficult to use, the railway a target and what little is functional will be used by the military, plus there is the big obstacle of the Appenin.
Basically except people that left for the South before or in the immediate of the invasion, the greater bulk of the italians will be forced to remain in North Italy.

I was trying to find the right balance for this as with the German invasion coming in a more convential sense rather than the fait accompli IOTL and with the lurid tales of German atrocities in the south I felt an exodus was inevitable to a certain extent but with the infrastructure and terrain it would be of a smaller scale compared to the refugees of May-June 1940 in NW Europe.

And now my usual remark towards the Allies...i know i look like a broken record but at this stage and with the foreshadowing of the famine of 1944 well the allied command need to take one a decision as if they left things on the own it's soo clear to be embarassing (really at the moment even a blind, mute, deaf and with some cerebral lesion individual will understand how grimm the situation is for the Caviglia government) that the current italian government will collapse and they will have on their hand an enourmous basketcase that will greatly hinder their operation so they need to activate some braincells and decide if they want to take direct control of the place or start give some seriouis help or even just some help. Even because Winston in London want to at least puppetize Italy and there is need an Italy left to puppetize and for now the only one that are making some serious inroad are the communist and this will not make him happy

The Allies certainly don't want a collapsed Italy on their hands or a Communist party able to take advantage of that but from their perspective they've made a deal with a government which now appears to be unravelling it. It was a somewhat less complex situation for them IOTL with the disentegration and flight of the govt in reaction to the German invasion, this is much more of a slow burn and provides opportunities to prop up the existing regime but also leaves them looking for alternatives within Italy.

As I understand it, the territory of RSI is much smaller than OTL. This could have the advantage that the defense forces can be much better concentrated and thus much more difficult to break through. The entire coastline to be defended is also smaller, which makes it more difficult for the Allies to carry out cargo operations here.

Yeah it's close to the OTL Gothic Line; north of the intended extent of the Allied advance and a tough nut to crack if they do decide to go further.

Have Germany and Croatia already annexed Italian territories such as Tyrol or Dalmatia?

Tyrol's been put under the same military occupation as Italy but as with OTL the Germanisation is a lot more blatant there, Dalmatia's annexed to Croatia under German supervision naturally.
 
The Allies certainly don't want a collapsed Italy on their hands or a Communist party able to take advantage of that but from their perspective they've made a deal with a government which now appears to be unravelling it. It was a somewhat less complex situation for them IOTL with the disentegration and flight of the govt in reaction to the German invasion, this is much more of a slow burn and provides opportunities to prop up the existing regime but also leaves them looking for alternatives within Italy.
I understand and agree with the reasoning, it's just that the allies are taking soo much time to decide that's the entire nation is on the road to collapse and they are still deciding if trust the current government, ok preparing for Overlord, but the operation will happen next year and in the meanwhile except their strategic bombing mission from Foggia they look like they are on a coffee breack and the goverment is unraveling because he face enormous challenges without even a minimal help so it's like a little hypocrite lament that they can't help because the goverment is weak. Frankly with this pace once they have decided something, the entire nation will be in anarky and Eisenowher will do the 'surprised Pikachu face', frankly if they want some alternitive they need simple say that they want some representation from such party or other concession and everybody knows that Caviglia and the King will not have any mean to refuse due to the current situation, so frankly at this stage is probable that even Grandi will simply ask what they want, to tell it openly because they are that desperate.
I was trying to find the right balance for this as with the German invasion coming in a more convential sense rather than the fait accompli IOTL and with the lurid tales of German atrocities in the south I felt an exodus was inevitable to a certain extent but with the infrastructure and terrain it would be of a smaller scale compared to the refugees of May-June 1940 in NW Europe.
Oh yeah the mass of refugee is inevitable, what i point will be different is the direction, the bulk will not go towards the South as with the Appenins, the lack of food and praticable road, well you need some knowledge of the zone to pass otherwise you risk to get lost and die. The main destination will be the various little town in the Pianura Padana, more easily accessible (by the locals) but still isolated enough to be 'probable' out of the main combat zone.
What i say is that migration will be mainly internal to North Italy, increasing the problems of lack of food or anything else, than towards south...not that a lot of people will not try due to panic but the greater part of them will not reach the destination alive, expecially old and very young people.
The main road that link north and south Italy aka the A1 (l'autostrada del sole) was a project started in 1955 before, well there was link in Rimini but as the Nazist have conquered it and start to round up people to build fortification, it will be too dangerous for big group of people pass through there.
For now the only real escape route from the big prison camp that's North Italy is through Liguria with ports and the railways that go towards Tuscany...if still usable, so an enormous numbers of people will try that
 
I understand and agree with the reasoning, it's just that the allies are taking soo much time to decide that's the entire nation is on the road to collapse and they are still deciding if trust the current government, ok preparing for Overlord, but the operation will happen next year and in the meanwhile except their strategic bombing mission from Foggia they look like they are on a coffee breack and the goverment is unraveling because he face enormous challenges without even a minimal help so it's like a little hypocrite lament that they can't help because the goverment is weak. Frankly with this pace once they have decided something, the entire nation will be in anarky and Eisenowher will do the 'surprised Pikachu face', frankly if they want some alternitive they need simple say that they want some representation from such party or other concession and everybody knows that Caviglia and the King will not have any mean to refuse due to the current situation, so frankly at this stage is probable that even Grandi will simply ask what they want, to tell it openly because they are that desperate.

Oh yeah the mass of refugee is inevitable, what i point will be different is the direction, the bulk will not go towards the South as with the Appenins, the lack of food and praticable road, well you need some knowledge of the zone to pass otherwise you risk to get lost and die. The main destination will be the various little town in the Pianura Padana, more easily accessible (by the locals) but still isolated enough to be 'probable' out of the main combat zone.
What i say is that migration will be mainly internal to North Italy, increasing the problems of lack of food or anything else, than towards south...not that a lot of people will not try due to panic but the greater part of them will not reach the destination alive, expecially old and very young people.
The main road that link north and south Italy aka the A1 (l'autostrada del sole) was a project started in 1955 before, well there was link in Rimini but as the Nazist have conquered it and start to round up people to build fortification, it will be too dangerous for big group of people pass through there.
For now the only real escape route from the big prison camp that's North Italy is through Liguria with ports and the railways that go towards Tuscany...if still usable, so an enormous numbers of people will try that
Many from Piedmont, and especially Lombardy will try to go to Switzerland. i mean, the border has plenty of woods and low mountain passes... A trickle of people, probably...
 
Many from Piedmont, and especially Lombardy will try to go to Switzerland. i mean, the border has plenty of woods and low mountain passes... A trickle of people, probably...
yep but honestly i expect the Swiss to stop the bulk of them and send them back as there was a limit of the number of refugee that they take due to the lack of international trade for isolation (OTL of the 50.000 italians, both civilians and military, that tried to enter swiss, 15.000 were sent back)
 
“A noi comunisti spettera di salvarla!”
“A noi comunisti spettera di salvarla!”




1712236551848.png





With the Regio Esercito in Northern Italy reduced to a handful of pockets of resistance, the SS Panzer Corps moved towards the original aim of the German invasion; the destruction of the Communist uprising which had caused the collapse of Mussolini’s regime. In Milan the PCI worked in the hope they might spark the same fate for Hitler.

The weeks following the uprising had been filled with hope and despair as well as muddy compromise however the internal Central Committee remained determined on the course of being the instigating factor in saving Italy from Mussolini and now German domination. Encouraged by Germany’s overwhelmingly bleak strategic picture and the tactical knowledge Luigi Longo had brought from prevailing over sieges in Spain, there appeared a method of saving the revolution even now the Germans were at the doorstep.

By the time the Germans had reached Rimini, the daily life for the remaining Milanese had become consumed with the construction of barricades and fortification of homes with the occasional breaks for drills and the provision of rations. Tens of thousands of workers were by now loosely organised into militia formations with a core of experienced veterans from the Eastern Front and Spanish Civil War.

They were armed with small arms, grenades, petrol bombs and a handful of anti-aircraft artillery pieces. Many more prepared to defend their homes with an assortment of bricks, shovels and bayonets. Some bore pikes and literal museum pieces from wars of the previous centuries;whenever possible the remnants of Milan’s ancient and mediaeval siege walls were incorporated into the defence.

The formerly Fascist printing presses which had been used to triumphantly announce the beginning of the Italian revolution in July now used their remaining paper and ink and provide one sheet summaries of the progress in fortifying the city, always concluding with the vow that Milan would be the Italian Stalingrad where the Germans would be halted and the workers would reap the rewards of their sacrifice.

Milan radio elaborated on these themes more colourfully, never losing its defiance despite the increasingly bleak situation. Umberto Massola spoke truthfully of how the Germans were in full retreat in Russia and less truthfully about the great Allied advance north which was coming to assist the revolutionary defence. If Milan fell, he warned, then the Germans would level the city and carry out the same massacres as they had in Poland and the Soviet Union, however if Milan could be held then the Germans would be forced to flee back behind the Alps and Milans workers would save Italy.

Many survivors of the battle for Milan would describe the prelude as a sort of daydream. The celebratory atmosphere had subsided but there remained an anticipation of the wonderful revolutionary society they might create within Italy. All the while they actively prepared for their homes to become a battleground amidst increasingly frequent Luftwaffe air raids in a city that was already half-empty.

By the end of August, the SS had reached the town of San Giuliano, meaning Milan was now within range of German artillery. Their bombardment of the city began in earnest, whilst final preparations were made for a multi-pronged assault on the city. Whilst the Communists promised an Italian Stalingrad, the SS Corps prepared for a repeat of the Third Battle of Kharkov where in March they had retaken the city from the overextended Red Army despite great cost. Now overextended themselves, they prepared the final stage of their Italian conquest.

The German advance had appeared unstoppable to many however by the time it was called to a halt at Rimini it was beginning to show the usual culminating signs of a blitzkrieg offensive. Italian resistance and terrain had taken its toll; the crossing of first the Alps and then several major rivers had been costly in men and material leaving the remainder at the end of a long and complicated supply line. The Italian defenders had few weapons capable of stopping the new Panther and Tiger tanks but many had been lost to breakdowns and were difficult to retrieve.

The situation felt ominous to some at Fuhrer Military Headquarters. Once again they had advanced deep into enemy territory against a seemingly disintegrating enemy only to come up against a vast city the Fuhrer wanted taken. Hitler, however, was increasingly confident Milan would prove little difficulty to his crack divisions after their dismantling of the Italian army in the field. Hausser arranged a temporary pause for his remaining troops to recuperate before ordering his panzers north.

The SS soldiers and tankers had been fighting near constantly since July with only a few days rest inbetween offensives. The Corps had been reinforced prior to crossing the Alps but the toll of Operation Citadel and the subsequent Italian operations had left it exhausted and depleted with around a third of its force having now become casualties. Nonetheless the deep ideological fanaticism of its officers had not been overestimated. Such men led from the front and were keen to eliminate an enemy characterised as the epitome of everything they had been taught to hate.

The Panzer Corps assault resembled that of the one against Kharkov with an advance against the south and west of the city by the Das Reich and Leibstandarte Adolf Hitler Panzer divisions respectively. The intention was to cut through the city defence, isolating pockets of resistance and impeding any Communist escape towards the coast. Meanwhile the Totenkopf division would advance in that direction, towards the Tyrrhenian Sea and La Spezia; the birthplace of the revolution.

The ideological zeal of the attackers was proven early on with the antics of one Leibstandarte field officer. Major Joachim Peiper ordered his tanks on a rampage into the city centre on the first day without pause for infantry support. These berserker tactics caused major disruption to the Milanese defence before running up against well prepared barricades. Peiper would die after his panzer was torched by a Molotov cocktail, a similar fate to many of his unit as they mounted a disorganised retreat.

Deprived of a quick victory the SS advance into the city became a protracted slog as the extent of the workers’ fortifications became apparent. Despite the German advantages in armour and airpower they were forced into a series of hand-to-hand battles with the militias, who used their local knowledge of the terrain to make up for the German superiority in small arms and training.

After a week of fighting Milan had become a mass grave for both attackers and defenders but particularly for what remained of its civilian population. Those sheltering in the cellars and sewers became the victims of constant bombardment, with no access to food, water or sanitation.

It was, for most, the fate of Pantelleria on a mass scale.


---​
 
honestly i doubt that after that Milan will be something more of a mass of ruins with enormous loss of lives for the italians; frankly i doubt that the communist militia can resist more than this week due to the sheer lack of equipment and the isolation of Milan and after a while the German command will simply go for bomb the place from a safe distance using both artillery and aircraft.
I see the italian government trying to muster up whatever left of the air force to both give some support to Milan and use the occasion to hit concentration of troops to ease any further pressure on the defensive line in the Appenin and the pocket in Turin.
Said that, well PCI military capacity is basically dead between Milan and soon la Spezia, the Germans will deal with them with extreme prejudice and zeal
Frankly the current italian government will try to milk this (the desperate battle in the alps, Milan, etc. etc) on the allied pubblic opinion as much as they can to obtain supply for the armed forces and the civilian population and by now at least Churchill will be more sympathetic due to his objective in the Balkan and in general to limit soviet gain and to achieve that target he need a functional allied italian government (plus he planned to get Regia Marina to fight in the Pacific)
 
Considering that the nazis are exhausted, overextended and have consumed most of their supplies massacring the civilians, I'd say now it's the perfect time for the Americans to swoop in, crush the Germans under the sheer weight of their war materiel and then make a movie when they give themselves all the merit.

Jokes aside, if there's a thing that can make the Allies get off their asses and go north is the remote possibility that the communist militia could actually hold the Germans at bay and win.
It just wouldn't do for post war Italy to get strange ideas on who actually liberated it, no?
 

Driftless

Donor
Have the Allies do an "Inchon" into la Spezia? (1) I don't know they have the sealift to pull that off. (2) How do they support and relieve that force? (3) They'd need a daring and adaptable top General to run the show.
 
“A noi comunisti spettera di salvarla!”




View attachment 898986




With the Regio Esercito in Northern Italy reduced to a handful of pockets of resistance, the SS Panzer Corps moved towards the original aim of the German invasion; the destruction of the Communist uprising which had caused the collapse of Mussolini’s regime. In Milan the PCI worked in the hope they might spark the same fate for Hitler.

The weeks following the uprising had been filled with hope and despair as well as muddy compromise however the internal Central Committee remained determined on the course of being the instigating factor in saving Italy from Mussolini and now German domination. Encouraged by Germany’s overwhelmingly bleak strategic picture and the tactical knowledge Luigi Longo had brought from prevailing over sieges in Spain, there appeared a method of saving the revolution even now the Germans were at the doorstep.

By the time the Germans had reached Rimini, the daily life for the remaining Milanese had become consumed with the construction of barricades and fortification of homes with the occasional breaks for drills and the provision of rations. Tens of thousands of workers were by now loosely organised into militia formations with a core of experienced veterans from the Eastern Front and Spanish Civil War.

They were armed with small arms, grenades, petrol bombs and a handful of anti-aircraft artillery pieces. Many more prepared to defend their homes with an assortment of bricks, shovels and bayonets. Some bore pikes and literal museum pieces from wars of the previous centuries;whenever possible the remnants of Milan’s ancient and mediaeval siege walls were incorporated into the defence.

The formerly Fascist printing presses which had been used to triumphantly announce the beginning of the Italian revolution in July now used their remaining paper and ink and provide one sheet summaries of the progress in fortifying the city, always concluding with the vow that Milan would be the Italian Stalingrad where the Germans would be halted and the workers would reap the rewards of their sacrifice.

Milan radio elaborated on these themes more colourfully, never losing its defiance despite the increasingly bleak situation. Umberto Massola spoke truthfully of how the Germans were in full retreat in Russia and less truthfully about the great Allied advance north which was coming to assist the revolutionary defence. If Milan fell, he warned, then the Germans would level the city and carry out the same massacres as they had in Poland and the Soviet Union, however if Milan could be held then the Germans would be forced to flee back behind the Alps and Milans workers would save Italy.

Many survivors of the battle for Milan would describe the prelude as a sort of daydream. The celebratory atmosphere had subsided but there remained an anticipation of the wonderful revolutionary society they might create within Italy. All the while they actively prepared for their homes to become a battleground amidst increasingly frequent Luftwaffe air raids in a city that was already half-empty.

By the end of August, the SS had reached the town of San Giuliano, meaning Milan was now within range of German artillery. Their bombardment of the city began in earnest, whilst final preparations were made for a multi-pronged assault on the city. Whilst the Communists promised an Italian Stalingrad, the SS Corps prepared for a repeat of the Third Battle of Kharkov where in March they had retaken the city from the overextended Red Army despite great cost. Now overextended themselves, they prepared the final stage of their Italian conquest.

The German advance had appeared unstoppable to many however by the time it was called to a halt at Rimini it was beginning to show the usual culminating signs of a blitzkrieg offensive. Italian resistance and terrain had taken its toll; the crossing of first the Alps and then several major rivers had been costly in men and material leaving the remainder at the end of a long and complicated supply line. The Italian defenders had few weapons capable of stopping the new Panther and Tiger tanks but many had been lost to breakdowns and were difficult to retrieve.

The situation felt ominous to some at Fuhrer Military Headquarters. Once again they had advanced deep into enemy territory against a seemingly disintegrating enemy only to come up against a vast city the Fuhrer wanted taken. Hitler, however, was increasingly confident Milan would prove little difficulty to his crack divisions after their dismantling of the Italian army in the field. Hausser arranged a temporary pause for his remaining troops to recuperate before ordering his panzers north.

The SS soldiers and tankers had been fighting near constantly since July with only a few days rest inbetween offensives. The Corps had been reinforced prior to crossing the Alps but the toll of Operation Citadel and the subsequent Italian operations had left it exhausted and depleted with around a third of its force having now become casualties. Nonetheless the deep ideological fanaticism of its officers had not been overestimated. Such men led from the front and were keen to eliminate an enemy characterised as the epitome of everything they had been taught to hate.

The Panzer Corps assault resembled that of the one against Kharkov with an advance against the south and west of the city by the Das Reich and Leibstandarte Adolf Hitler Panzer divisions respectively. The intention was to cut through the city defence, isolating pockets of resistance and impeding any Communist escape towards the coast. Meanwhile the Totenkopf division would advance in that direction, towards the Tyrrhenian Sea and La Spezia; the birthplace of the revolution.

The ideological zeal of the attackers was proven early on with the antics of one Leibstandarte field officer. Major Joachim Peiper ordered his tanks on a rampage into the city centre on the first day without pause for infantry support. These berserker tactics caused major disruption to the Milanese defence before running up against well prepared barricades. Peiper would die after his panzer was torched by a Molotov cocktail, a similar fate to many of his unit as they mounted a disorganised retreat.

Deprived of a quick victory the SS advance into the city became a protracted slog as the extent of the workers’ fortifications became apparent. Despite the German advantages in armour and airpower they were forced into a series of hand-to-hand battles with the militias, who used their local knowledge of the terrain to make up for the German superiority in small arms and training.

After a week of fighting Milan had become a mass grave for both attackers and defenders but particularly for what remained of its civilian population. Those sheltering in the cellars and sewers became the victims of constant bombardment, with no access to food, water or sanitation.

It was, for most, the fate of Pantelleria on a mass scale.


---​
Oh no, I'm never born! My poor grampa for sure ended bombed or heroically died defending Porta Ticinese (he was 22 and had military experience, besides being a socialista...)
 
Last edited:
Have the Allies do an "Inchon" into la Spezia? (1) I don't know they have the sealift to pull that off. (2) How do they support and relieve that force? (3) They'd need a daring and adaptable top General to run the show.
More than an Inchon, if the Allies want to really do something, they can launch an air campaign against the column targeting La Spezia as the nazist are spent by the heavy fight in the italian north east and are at the limit of their logistic line, eliminate the german attack, build force in Genoa and La Spezia and lauch a counterattack towards Milan while the nazist need to rebuild their forces.
But this mean that the allies at least stop nagging about the italian government not being trustworthy while holding them by the balls and sacrificing what remain of the Italian Army to degrade the German capacity
 
Corpses on Holiday
Corpses on Holiday





1713114721998.png




The Germans had captured some two thirds of the city after the first week however the toll it had taken was enough to give even Hitler pause. German casualties numbered in the thousands alongside dozens of panzers, these were unsustainable losses despite the ideological motivations at play.

Hitler ordered what remained of the Das Reich and Leibstandarte Divisions out of the city and back into open country where they could consolidate the conquest of northern Italy. They would limp out of the city in the following days, exhausted and embarrassed, keen to take out these frustrations on the Italians already under German occupation.

Eliminating what remained of Communist resistance would be left to SS units newly arriving from ‘anti-partisan’ operations in Belarus. The consensus at Fuhrer Military Headquarters was that the battle was effectively over in Milan, all that remained was to ‘pacify’ the city in order for it to be restructured as a hub for German war industries. It was considered best not to squander elite troops and equipment when the mop-up could be carried out by units which were far more dispensable.

It was true that the situation for Milan’s defenders had become desperate, withstanding the German onslaught had taken the lives of tens of thousands. For many more the ordeal had become unbearable with many deserters attempting to flee the city or ride out the storm with their families underground. Those who remained were condensed into pockets within the centre and north of Milan, communications and supplies had broken down with ammunition and food having become scarce.

Leadership had also largely vanished, much of the PCI Central Committee died in the first days of the fighting, including Luigi Longo himself. Umberto Massola had been silenced by the destruction of Milan’s radio broadcast centre but allegedly could be heard wandering the streets chanting slogans either in defiance or delirium. Regardless of whether these claims were true it appears his propaganda continued to echo in the minds of survivors even after his martyrdom.

The end of Massola’s broadcasts cut off the tenuous link between the defenders of Milan and the outside world. German propaganda was keen to ignore the ordeal their troops were experiencing there and the chaos in northern Italy made fact and rumour almost indistinguishable for those in the rest of the country.

Allied intelligence hinted at heavy German losses, information that Allied Supreme Commander Dwight Eisenhower waited for greater confirmation of. Any potential for Allied exploitation of the potential opportunity for an advance to the Alps or a landing at La Spezia was largely lost due to this caution. The German halt at Rimini had appeared to shut off northern Italy from immediate liberation in Allied minds.

It was easier to dismiss the defence of Milan as a useful source for killing Germans but one that shouldn’t be taken as an excuse to waste further Allied lives and resources given attention had already turned to the cross channel invasion of France intended for the following year.

Despite Allied doubts about their determination to resist, German appeals to surrender went largely ignored by the militias. The wave of atrocities which had already swept Italy left little incentive to trust in German promises of good treatment. SS actions within the city had deepened the enmity, their liberal use of Milanese civilians as human shields and willingness to murder anyone suspected of resistance having hardened the defender’s resolve.

The apparent withdrawal of most German units from Milan after the heavy fighting bolstered hopes that victory was near. Cut-off from the outside world it appeared possible the Allies might be advancing on the city and forcing a German retreat. This gave further motivation for the remaining defenders to endure a little longer. In reality Allied command lacked a clear picture of the battle within the city and continued to focus on consolidating their gains below the Apennines. The Germans had marked what was left of Milan for wholesale slaughter, albeit with units more expendable than their elite armoured divisions.

Among the ‘anti-partisan’ units arriving in Italy were the infamous Dirlewangler Brigade, composed of former prison and concentration camp inmates and named after its commander, Oskar Dirlewangler. Their unspeakable brutality had spread devastation wherever they roamed in occupied Belarus. Their tactics of massacring entire villages suspected of partisan activity would now be deployed in Milan.

They would be the spearhead of some 16,000 troops of the ‘Ost Battalions’ composed of Soviet prisoners of war, pressed or persuaded into fighting against the Red Army. The Kursk debacle and subsequent need to retreat had made the prospects of a decisive victory in the East increasingly vague and the German suspicion of their slave soldiers grew. It was decided they would be used as cannon fodder in the Italian interior.

The second German offensive into Milan would not begin until the end of September, at which point the defenders had already become further worn down. The hopes of Allied rescue had vanished, disease and starvation had begun to take its toll. Cholera and typhus reared their heads and a sense of hopelessness grew with them. A steady exodus trickled out of the city, when the German offensive was renewed it would become a stampede.

This new campaign was chaotic, a ‘pacification’ limited mostly to armed bands with small arms and grenades massacring civilians wholesale regardless of whether or not they had chosen to fight. The hand to hand fighting remained brutal, the Germans no longer having the same superiority in weaponry but the physical deterioration of defenders gave them a new advantage. For Milanese civilians it was a new nightmare, relentless bombardment from air and artillery was replaced by murderers lurking around any corner, sweeping the city of any life they came across.

These atrocities had their desired effect and any remaining cohesion to the defence broke down. The Germans and their slave soldiers endured heavy casualties with little regard made for their safety by their commanders. Many within the Ost Battalions attempted to desert, mostly to be discovered in the ruins and executed along with any Milanese the SS came across. Getting out of the city became the focus for most of the remaining Milanese and as such the need to defend it largely evaporated.

Isolated pockets of resistance would continue to endure in Milan until the end of the war, carrying out elaborate hit and run tactics before disappearing into the elaborate ruins, however by October the Wehrmacht had imposed some semblance of order in the city. Slave labourers under the yoke of the German Organisation Todt would be marched in to rebuild the city industry for German uses. By this time most of the remaining Milanese population had been transported to labour in Germany under similar conditions.


---
 
Stalin iotl was furious on WAllies for just meeting with Germans in Italy in April 1945 and demanded USSR presence.
I wonder how Stalin sees the non help of Milan ittl.
 
A pair of grim but otherwise expected updates. The Allied strategy seems realistic IMO. However La Spezia might throw a spanner into the works. Guess we'll see.

I highly doubt the Allies are going to push further north than Rimini in 1943 or 1944. With Rome in their hands, the political driver for the Italian campaign is effectively gone. This could free up substantial troops for France, perhaps allowing for a landing in Southern France in Spring '44 (A true "Operation Anvil" or a larger D-Day landing.) Given that the Allies won't be able to practice a large scale opposed amphibious landing with no Salerno in TTL and no need for a landing at Anzio, I wonder if they try to do something other than sit on their hands before D-day. Southern France seems the most likely IMO.
 

Driftless

Donor
An AH hypothetical question (double hypothetical?), is how that level of utter brutality in would affect post-war relations between Italy and Germany, and even to the extent of an altered NATO?
 
An AH hypothetical question (double hypothetical?), is how that level of utter brutality in would affect post-war relations between Italy and Germany, and even to the extent of an altered NATO?
Between that and the foreshadowing treatment of the italans, well things will be much worse than OTL, frankly i doubt that ITTL the persecution of the germans who committed war crime here will be de facto ceased by put all the documentation in a phisical archive and litteraly bury that in an office with the order of never opening or letting criminals like Herbert Keppler escape.
Not considering the situation in South Tyrol/Alto Adige, OTL all the previously emigrated german population was let come back without any real background check regarding nazist activity, i doubt that will happen OTL

Stalin iotl was furious on WAllies for just meeting with Germans in Italy in April 1945 and demanded USSR presence.
I wonder how Stalin sees the non help of Milan ittl.
Stalin was furious to have been left out due to fear that the Allies will get a better position in Italy at communist (and so URSS) expense, ITTL at the moment he had other things to deal and the PCI is basically dead as a fighting force so better concentrate over the damned second front, honestly the bulk of his protest is why the allies don't push through north Italy to take pressure away from the URSS because they need it now and not the next year
 
Top